SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA - SEPTEMBER 08: Christian Crichton of the Panthers celebrates scoring a try with team mates during the NRL Elimination Final match between the Penrith Panthers and the New Zealand Warriors at ANZ Stadium on September 8, 2018 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

Pre-Season Prediction: 5th

Actual Finish: 5th (Second week of finals)

A rare, spot on prediction. The Panthers lost some talent but recruited well over all.

Although we ultimately correctly predicted the Panthers 5th placed finish, no one in their right mind would have predicted the manner in which the Panthers finished the 2018 season.

The Star: Viliame Kikau

The Fijian wrecking ball won the Panthers’ members Player of the Year and would be the player who caused more nightmares for opposition defenders than any others.

His barnstorming run off the kick of the semi final against the Sharks summed up his season. He dominated all in front of him with size, strength, football and genuine footballing ability.

It’s scary to think this kid is still only 23 years of age. The 2017 World Cup really saw the emergence of the second rower but 2018 saw him develop into one of the game’s elite forwards.

His efforts during the early rounds were enough to earn a further three years extension onto his contract at increased terms. The move was smart as there wouldn’t be a club in the NRL who couldn’t use Kikau’s talents moving forward.

Season highlight: Multiple comebacks

I literally lost count of the amount of times the Panthers came back to win from seemingly impossible deficits.

Despite being 18-0 down to a rampaging Sharks outfit, the Panthers almost stole the chocolates one last time. It was fitting that they couldn’t quite get there to end their season.

SEE ALSO:  Phil Gould calls for NRL expansion

Few will forget the comeback against Manly. The Panthers were dead to rights with only a few minutes to go. Try after try after try saw Penrith capture it late and consign Manly to the most frustrating of defeats.

It seemed like every second week the Panthers fell 14-or-so behind, only to fly home and capture a win.

For Panthers fans it was frustrating as all get out, but for us neutrals, it was fun fun fun.

Break Out Star: Issah Yeo

The 23-year-old really came of age in 2018, winning the Panthers’ player of the year award. He was named captain in the absence of James Maloney through Origin and then injury.

Making over 31 tackles per game as well as over 112 metres, Yeo is the model of consistency and hard work. He doesn’t have the highlight reel of Kikau but he is equally as important to the Panthers.

Yeo put his name into genuine Origin contention, and although he did not represent his state, his name will be right there again next year following his 2018 season.


It’s a case of what could have been at the foot of the mountains. What if they hadn’t left their run so late? What if they had removed Anthony Griffin earlier, or not at all?

What if Dylan Edwards didn’t get injured just as he was peaking with some impressive form?

SEE ALSO:  Blake hit with charge for push on Eels' Moses

What if Maloney didn’t fall to injury after the Origin period?

We’ll never know, but over all the Panthers can be very proud of their efforts in 2018.

2018 saw stars emerge, both their halves combine for an Origin victory, and a plethora or key re-signings.

Season Grade: B+

Penrith ultimately fell short of the ultimate goal, which is a Grand Final appearance.

Their 2018 bogey side, the Sharks, ended their season in front of a Panther dominated semi-final crowd.

Considering the season relied on hail-mary comebacks though has to have the Panthers brass more than a little worried. Literally a point or two either way and the Panthers could have finished anywhere from first to ninth.

Overall Panthers fans should be happy with the results. This squad was up to a top four finish, and they only just missed out on such.

That said, they haven’t been past week two of the finals in a long time, and have finished 6th, 7th and 5th across the past three seasons.

I suppose that is a gradual improvement, but for a side this talented, I’m sure the Panthers could have gone at least that one week further, thus earning them slightly less than an A grade.

It’s hard to find too many negatives, at least on field for the mountain men. They’re well placed for 2019 and beyond IF they can get their vision and coaching plan sorted sooner rather than later.


  1. Not sure they will be as high up next season.
    Many first graders lost over the last two seasons. Then only one real first grader ( Maloney ) signed from elsewhere.
    They haven’t really looked to strengthen positions that have been weaker. At least one good centre is required. Lacked a bit of pace on one wing. A real firebrand type of player is required up front.
    Maybe locals juniors can strengthen them further? As every age group & grade that represented the area made the finals in 2018.
    No matter what anyone says about Ivan, he has more talent as a coach than Griffin. Maybe he can get them to tackle better, as he did with Wests.

  2. As long as Nathan’s happy, Gus will be happy. From what I can see of their deals.
    He’s got lots of other coaches to assist with teaching defence there as well.

  3. Penrith are the smokey’s for the premiership in 2019. Their two main issues are hooker and right centre, Katoa has his moments and is solid most of the time and Egan after having his first year in and around FG may have learned enough. Whare can be a brilliant defensive centre, but due to a bad injury last year struggled in attack, maybe he will come back bigger and stronger in 2019. Their left side in attack is as good as any in the NRL. Losing their fullback Dylan Edwards early in the season didn’t help their cause, and with DWZ filling in while obviously injured thwarted their campaign. Edwards is a great defender and needs to cover on the left side to help Maloney out, and I’m sure that is something they will work on. Kikau was a monster and is still only young, he will be a bigger monster in 2019, after Taumalolo he is the best running back rower in the game. Prop may be another issue (Merrin gone..but no great loss) if Hetherington can curb his aggression and silly play he will fill the void, along with Leota. They are definitely the dark horse for 2019.

    • I agree. Edwards was a big loss early in the season in 2018. Was just starting to set up plays out wide, as he’d done in the lower grades. Was the best yardage maker from backing up in the competition.
      Losing forwards early in the year to injury didn’t help. Though I didn’t think Merrion had a good year at all & wasn’t much of a prop when used there. They were overrun by harder hitting packs early in games. Except the game against St.George.
      Plenty of good young forwards coming through. They need to step up.
      Can’t understand why they don’t replace Whare. He’s not good enough.
      Would have been better to keep the much bigger, faster Sivo for the wing also. Then let Mansour go. Mansour may be a good yardage maker. He still gets run around by much faster opposition wingers.

      • I agree also…Edwards though will tighten that left side in defence, put it this way I’d rather him defending their than Moylan, Moylan’s defence was awful anywhere near the line. Mansour had a couple of very serious injuries that would have dented his confidence though, I see him having a big 2019. Plus Blake..he was injured and made big improvement in 2018..he was close to the best centre towards the end of the year. All looking good on the left for the Panthers next year , will be top 4 without any doubt.

Comments are closed.