AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND - AUGUST 10: Kalyn Ponga of the Knights looks on during warmup prior to the round 22 NRL match between the New Zealand Warriors and the Newcastle Knights at Mt Smart Stadium on August 10, 2018 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Anthony Au-Yeung/Getty Images)

I have a small problem with the recent Kalyn Ponga situation.

First things first – I must say that I am a huge admirer of him as a player and on the surface of it as a man in the way he conducts himself, as is everyone else in rugby league but there is just one thing that really irks me.

I love the step. I love the fact he joined the struggling Knights from the high-flying Cowboys. I love that he muscled up in the middle in State of Origin. I saw the YouTube clips playing for Churchie and was amazed at his debut. I love watching him play football.

What gets me is the news that he dreams to play for the All Blacks. The New Zealand National rugby union team, arguably the greatest sporting side in the world. Given their small population and absolute domination of the game as a Kiwi it would be an honour to pull on that jersey and be a part of all it represents, except for one detail. Ponga decided he wanted to play for Queensland and Australia at representative level in rugby league.

Now, I realise that the situation is a bit complex. Born in Western Australia to New Zealander parents, moving to QLD as a young child for eight years, then spending five years across the ditch on the North Island before heading back to the Sunshine state it is understandable that one might be torn as to which nation they may want to represent.

SEE ALSO:  The team that New South Wales must pick

Kalyn chose Australia.

The fact is playing State of Origin is lucrative. I’m sure lots of players would play in the game of highest intensity rugby league for free, but $30,000 in the pocket is a nice kicker and very fair given the commercial appeal that the series generates. Given there are three games without fail each and every year it is understandable that it can sway a player to choose Australia over another nation.

Money aside, pulling on your nations jersey has to be the biggest source of pride in any sport, knowing you would push yourself past your limits for the man next to you and believing they would do the same for you in the name of your homeland. If a player is already dreaming of playing for another country in a rival code I’m not really sure their heart is completely in it.

Despite all of this, perhaps it’s personal emotion of being a long-suffering NSW Blues and Wallabies fan that makes me wish such a prodigal talent would pull on the gold of Australia. I wish he dreamt of being part of the first team since 2002 to bring the Bledisloe Cup back, rather than being part of the irresistible tide that is All Black success. He is currently aspiring to play for the Kangaroos, that aside from a couple of years of lull at the turn of the decade have always been a similarly dominant force in international rugby league.

SEE ALSO:  Predicted Queensland team for State of Origin I

If State of Origin wasn’t around how many more players would pledge their allegiance to the Kiwi’s or smaller nations? I love that players are starting to represent their Pacific Islands nations out of choice and not as a fall-back option. International rugby league needs a boost and the best players all choosing Australia isn’t helping.

I have always held great admiration for players such as Benji Marshall, Kieran Foran and Jason Taulamlolo for choosing the Kiwis over State of Origin. Time will tell if Ponga decides to try his luck at rugby, in which no doubt he will be a success. It is not as easy road, cite Marshall in 2014, but he has the ability to do anything – he is genuinely a once in a generation talent.

I cannot wait to see Ponga pull on the green and gold and represent Australia, however seeing him then do the Haka will be difficult to take as they stroll to another 50-point walk over at Eden Park.


  1. It was a comment made after being asked about it at the end of an interview whilst he was in New Zealand after a game.
    Far too much is being made of that comment.

  2. The problem is that as always the idea that the person must be considered “australian” to play state of origin.

    Many kiwi/tongan juniors grew up playing league in QLD / NSW. They pretend to be “Australian” so they can play state of origin.. NOT to play for australia.

    To me, the solution is simple. Split the concept of “state” and “national” allegiance and stop forcing kiwi players to play for australia because they want to play for their state. Fix the state eligibility rules to exclude players that really have no business playing for state.

    In no way would this dilute the concept because kiwi / tongan players are already exploiting the system to play for lower tier nations / australia as it is. It barely makes any difference.

    International NRL is a farce and one of the main reasons for that is state of origin. If they changed the eligibility, barely anything would change about SOO. How many kiwi players would be playing origin right now? Basically none of them. If they grew up in NSW though, they should be able to play for NSW. End of story.

  3. If you are a “resident” in Australia – play for whoever you like. If you are a “citizen” of Australia – you play for Australia, and any of the States within it that you reside.

  4. Absolutely agree with that. If you are born here , play for Australia.
    It’s fine to use this country & what it offers as you grow up. Fine to use our coaching , facilities in what ever sport you choose. Then to say ‘ You Know What, I Think I’m Really a New Zealander ‘. Or Tongan, Samoan , English . Born here , play for your country of birth.
    Plenty of the population have links ( most of the population ), to other countries. It’s not just a training ground for other countries.

  5. Just on Andrew Fafita. Now plays for Tonga. He played for a team in the NSW Koori knock out tournament at the end of the season a year or two ago.
    He’s part Koori then. Yet he only shows pride in his Tongan heritage , by playing for Tonga. You couldn’t be more Australian than being Koori.

Comments are closed.