The NRL will allow players to challenge their assessed market value in exceptional circumstances, potentially opening the door for Hudson Young's proposed move to the PNG Chiefs.

The development comes after the salary cap auditor rejected a reported $900,000-a-season offer from the incoming Papua New Guinea franchise for the Canberra Raiders forward, with the amount deemed to be below his assessed market value.

Young's valuation was initially set at $1.1 million before being reduced to $1 million, creating complications for the Chiefs as they attempt to assemble their inaugural roster ahead of entering the competition in 2028.

NRL Rd 1 – Raiders v Warriors
LAS VEGAS, NEVADA - MARCH 01: Hudson Young of the Raiders celebrates winning the round one NRL match between the Canberra Raiders and the New Zealand Warriors at Allegiant Stadium on March 01, 2025, in Las Vegas, Nevada. (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)

However, the NRL's latest position could allow Young to challenge his current assessment, with his season-ending Achilles injury potentially providing grounds for a reduction that would bring him closer to the Chiefs' original offer.

NRL executive chairman Peter V'landys confirmed the governing body had discussed the possibility of exceptional circumstances with the Rugby League Players Association (RLPA), opening the door for players to contest their assessed value.

“The salary cap applies to everybody and requires the market value of a player,” V'landy's told the Sydney Morning Herald.

“In saying that, we've discussed it with the RLPA – and we both agree – there can be exceptional circumstances. We will always look at exceptional circumstances."

RLPA CEO Clint Newton also shared his thoughts on the situation.

“I certainly believe that if PNG want to pay him $900,000, that shouldn't be stopped,” Newton said of the Young situation.

“I understand if something doesn't smell right from an integrity perspective, but that's not the case here.

“I said to Peter, ‘I don't want us to go down the legal path here, but my greatest concern is clubs are trying to put the genie back in the bottle'. Everyone has been very aware of the tax-free money, and no one batted an eyelid.

“Now it seems as though because PNG are doing well from a recruitment perspective, these things are being put up as a roadblock."

The situation surrounding Young has highlighted the challenges the NRL faces in regulating the PNG Chiefs' recruitment, with tax-free exemptions expected to provide the franchise with a significant advantage in attracting players.

Those benefits could allow players to receive a higher take-home income than they would at rival clubs, even if their contracted salaries are lower, creating an additional complication when determining market value under the salary cap.

Broncos announce historic trial match in PNG
PORT MORESBY, PAPUA NEW GUINEA - NOVEMBER 05: Papua New Guinean fans show their support during the 2017 Rugby League World Cup match between Papua New Guinea Kumuls and Ireland on November 5, 2017 in Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

As a result, the Chiefs' proposed $900,000-a-season deal for Young was knocked back because it fell below his assessed value, despite the potential financial benefits he could receive by signing with the new franchise.

A successful challenge could see Young's market value reduced to $900,000, potentially allowing the Chiefs to fit the forward into their salary cap plans without exceeding the NRL's requirements.

However, any reassessment would need to satisfy the governing body's criteria, with the forward's injury history potentially becoming a significant factor in determining his value.

The Raiders, meanwhile, are making a substantial push to retain one of their key forwards after initially offering Young a three-year contract worth $3.3 million.

Canberra have since upgraded their offer to a reported $4.4 million over four seasons in a desperate attempt to keep Young in the nation's capital.

With the NRL now prepared to consider challenges to market valuations in exceptional circumstances, Young's situation could become an early test of how the governing body handles disputes involving the incoming PNG franchise.

A revised assessment would not guarantee a move to the Chiefs, but it could give the club greater flexibility in pursuing the Raiders forward as they continue preparations for their NRL debut.