Rugby league is a sport obsessed with superstars and highlight moments, so it's easy to overlook the players who may not dominate headlines or win the end-of-year awards.
What makes these players underrated is that teammates lean on them, coaches trust them and they shape results without the plaudits.
Every club has someone like this, the unsung hero that keeps the team moving, the player whose influence runs deeper than most think.
So, before the next headline rolls in, let's take a moment to appreciate them, the most underrated players at each NRL club.
Wests Tigers
A year ago, it would've been Fonua Pole.
At the start of the season, it would've been Adam Doueihi.
Now, it's Starford To'a.
Unfortunately for To'a his season was cut short due to shoulder injury, limiting him to 19 games.
But in those 19 games, he had 17 direct try contributions and averaged 103 metres per game.
But with all the focus this season on Terrell May, Jarome Luai and Jahream Bula, it's clear why To'a lacks a lot of plaudits.
Get set for the footy with the FREE Zero Tackle 2026 NRL Season Guide! Packed with 130+ pages of player profiles, team previews, insights and analysis, the 2026 NRL Season Guide is built for fans who want the full picture. Download your free Season Guide HERE.
Connor Tracey.
Under-appreciated by the coaches at the Sharks, so he left.
Now he is under-appreciated at the Bulldogs.
The league’s perennial “Mr. Overlooked’
CT is very underrated, the reason Raiders got Brailey was because they thought they might not be able to re-sign Starling as they wanted to re-sign Fogarty and Alamoti is underrated as well.