GOSFORD, AUSTRALIA - JULY 01: Valentine Holmes of the Sharks runs the ball during the round 17 NRL match between the Sydney Roosters and the Cronulla Sharks at Central Coast Stadium on July 1, 2017 in Gosford, Australia. (Photo by Tony Feder/Getty Images)

We’re just one round into the 2018 NRL season and already one coach is facing a decision that will certainly affect his club’s 2018 season, but also possibly the long-term future of the club as well.

That man is Cronulla Sharks coach Shane Flanagan who must decide on how best to fit Josh Dugan, Matt Moylan and Valentine Holmes into the run-on 13 in order to maximise output from his three-star attacking players.

All the pre-season talk in the shire centred around how the side would line up. The trial form indicated that Valentine Holmes would return to the role at fullback, one in which he filled in 2017.

The Sharks had a disappointing 2017 season after failing to reproduce the attacking football of 2016 that saw them end their 49-year title drought.

The biggest difference between the 2016 and 2017 editions of the Sharks came due to Ben Barba’s release from the club. The Sharks sorely missed his ball-playing abilities. They too missed the impact of Holmes on the wing after the youngster shifted into the custodian role.

Despite having an absolute blinder in the trial against the Tigers, Holmes turned in a nightmare performance last Friday night against the Cowboys.

Calls have already surfaced for Holmes to be returned to the wing allowing star recruit Josh Dugan to see far more ball than was afforded to him in the centres.

Holmes, arguably the best winger in the game right now, stared for the Kangaroos in the World Cup on the flank. He also made the difference for Queensland in the 2017 Origin series, again on the wing.

The general belief in the Shire is that the Sharks are a far stronger side with Holmes on the wing, allowing either the hard running Dugan or the ball playing Moylan to slot into the number one.

The only problem is that Holmes, understandably, has his focus purely on the fullback spot.

It’s only natural that a young player who stared in the role in the lower grades would want the extra responsibility and money that comes along with the number one jersey.

SEE ALSO:  Updated Team Lists: Bulldogs vs Eels

The Sharks had to fight off genuine interest from the Cowboys, Val’s home-town team, to re-sign their prized asset. It was no secret that Holmes was seen as the club’s long-term number one, and Val was paid as much.

Holmes was chosen in the role over Jack Bird, with Bird eventually moving onto the Broncos in order to see more ball. The Sharks seemingly chose Holmes over Bird.

Any decision to shift Holmes back to the wing could potentially upset a player who is signed only until the end of 2019, with an option for the 2020 season.

Following the Sharks trip to Townsville, there have been unconfirmed talks of Holmes being homesick. As a 22-year-old who has lived away from home for the better part of five years, you can’t begrudge him that feeling, if they are indeed true.

Coupled with the off-contract status of Cowboys number one Lachlan Coote it’s not a huge jump to see the possibility of Holmes in a Cowboys jumper in the future.

Any decision to move Holmes to the wing long-term may realistically shape the career of Holmes. Although I believe Holmes to be the most valuable winger in the game, it’s not unfair to question why a side would pay a winger in the same bracket as a top fullback.

Holmes may yet develop into one of the game’s best number ones. He certainly has the talent. Some of his efforts in the role last year for the Sharks were eye-watering. His ability to break the line has defences on edge and looking out for him.

Yes his ball playing ability if not up there with the likes of Slater, Boyd or even team-mate Moylan, but at 22 he’s not yet a finished product.

The Sharks showed their hand in the off-season in offering Mitchell Pearce a huge deal to sign for the club. The thought was that with Pearce and Townsend in the halves, Moylan at fullback, Dugan at centre and Holmes on the wing, the side would be better than even their 2016 premiership side.

SEE ALSO:  Eels suspend Terepo

Unfortunately, Pearce opted for the challenge in the Hunter but the signing of former Origin halfback Trent Hodkinson looked to renew those thoughts.

The presence of Dugan and Moylan, two Origin-level fullbacks, was always going to put pressure on Flanagan should his first-choice fullback fail to fire early on.

Although it has only been one week, and a loss to the premiership favourites, the Sharks need to ensure Josh Dugan sees far more ball than he has in the pre-season and round one. Moving him to fullback will certainly make the side more dangerous, while Holmes on the wing will give opposition markers nightmares.

Alternatively, Hodkinson coming into the halves, freeing Moylan up to return to the number one role would see Dugan and Holmes reform their World Cup-winning partnership. For mine THAT is the strongest Sharks side. Holmes and Dugan can roam for the ball while Moylan can play as a third half.

There’s no real doubt that short-term, Holmes on the wing makes the Sharks are far more dangerous outfit.

That said, it could also have a very real and long-lasting effect on the future for the club.

If Holmes is willing to serve his time on the wing and develop under Moylan and Dugan, he could very well become something ridiculously special for Shane Flanagan.

On the other hand, if he sees the move as a demotion, the Sharks loss could be the Cowboys gain.


For those looking to kill 50-or-so minutes before tonight’s local derby, The Fins Up Podcast streamed here presents a (not so) slightly black, white and blue bias on all things rugby league. Come join us for a laugh and some banter.


  1. The Sharks are 15-9 with Holmes at fullback. 15-9 is good enough to get you a top 4 finish most seasons, it’s a pretty good record. I’d stick with Holmes at fullback, he”s not the first fullback that Thurston has got the better of and certainly won’t be the last. What happens if Dugan plays a bad game at fullback? Do they then stick Moylan there? Then what happens if he has a bad game?

  2. Moylan is a crap FB, he was terrible in SOO, Dugan is the only choice for FB, they have no dilemma, it’s a beat up.

  3. everything zt says makes sense. what to do? Giving holmes a chance does make sense. Geez I’m glad I’m not Flanno.
    Does Flanno jnr have a good kicking game does anyone know?

  4. Very sensible decision by Flanagan, Dugan at fullback and Holmes on the wing, Holmes to me very overrated, anyway putting Grey at centre is their best option, to me he is their best buy, will be awesome in that backline, they have got it right and should put saints away in this match

  5. Doesn’t matter who those classless losers have at fullback or any other position, as tonight showed, they’re completely rubbish. I love how they have 3 guys on “fullback’s money” when all 3 are rubbish fullbacks.

    • As opposed to say a guy who’s best position is hooker and on over $1 mil per year? From a supporter of a club that is famous for paying overs it may be a little early to speak. We also seem to recall a side winning 6 of their first 7 last season and still missed the finals. There weren’t any signs there last night to suggest anything will be different this season. Sharks beat themselves. Time will tell who’s rubbish by September yet again……

      • Well your analysis is what might be called faulty. Hunt having a few good games at hooker doesn’t make that his best position. And I saw plenty of differences last night as opposed to last year. a halfback that knows what he’s doing, Graham’s professionalism, destroying the broncos and coming back from 14-0 down in an away game. Want to check your facts again?

        • Exactly what “facts” have I missed that you would be ranting about there Sunshine? In light of recent history, the delusional bit would have to be a dragons fan getting overly excited after 2 rounds……

        • The facts I just stated genius. I guess being a Cronulla supporter reading probably isn’t your thing. And instead of looking at history, maybe you should look forward – specifically your draw. We’ll see who is crowing when you’re probably going 0-6 come April hahaha. Even a good hit of peptides won’t be enough help

  6. If Val doesn’t get the No1 job he is likely to become disgruntled and play like a tool all year. If it does play out like it is looking expect Val to part company with the shire at seasons end.

  7. Sharks their own worst enemies 2 wks in a row. Should have put the dragqueens & their toothless brassy fans away.

    • Toothless brassy fans? Did you not see the gummies fans on the box last night? BTW, you support who?

  8. Perhaps Cronulla needs to take the soft way out too and merge with another club? Although that doesn’t seem to bring startling results now does it?

Comments are closed.